Nate’s Nightmare Fuel returns for Volume 5! Special guest Mr. Soup (Steve Polivka) joins Andy and Jo as they subject Nate to three horror movies: May, Come True, and Evil Dead Burn. We review all three films, react to the scares, and find out whether Nate can survive another round of cinematic torture. Three movies. One terrified Nate. Plenty of regret!
R&R 170: 31 Movies. 31 Nights. Countless Regrets! | Halloween Horrorcast 2026
It’s the annual Rum & Regret Halloween Horrorcast! Andy and special guest Steve Polivka (Mr. Soup) recap their 31 for 31 October Horror Movie Challenge.
R&R 169: 31 Nights of Frights, Carrie & Mr. Soup!
We’re talking our 31 for 31 Halloween Horror Movie Challenge, sharing our favorite frights and biggest disappointments, and reviewing Amazon Prime’s Carrie series. Horror, laughs, hot takes, and a whole lot of regret!
R&R 168: October Horror, Marvel Madness & Lanterns: The Final Verdict
October brings the scares as Jo previews the hottest horror releases, Andy and Jo tackle Evil Dead Burn, and Nate delivers the latest Marvel news. Plus, Andy rants about Avengers: Endgame Encore, and the crew gives its final verdict on HBO Max’s Lanterns. Pour a drink and let the regret begin!
R&R 167: Marvel Madness, Horror Hype & Lanterns!
Marvel news, horror TV and gaming updates, and more HBO’s Lanterns! The Rum & Regret crew tackles the latest superhero developments, upcoming scares, and DC’s cosmic mysteries in Episode 167.
R&R 166: Legends Never Fade: Tim Curry, Dolly Parton & Peter Cullen
This week, Rum & Regret raises a glass to Tim Curry, Dolly Parton, and Peter Cullen—three legendary performers whose voices, talent, and careers have left an undeniable mark on pop culture. Come celebrate the legends with us!
R&R 165: Lanterns, Mutants & Obsession | D23 Recap
Nate finally watches Obsession, we break down the Lanterns premiere, and then dive headfirst into all the biggest D23 reveals—including the Ashoka Season 2 trailer and the newly revealed X-Men cast. Another round of opinions, theories, and regret awaits!
R&R 164: From Dark Helmet to Doomsday. Comic-Con 26 Wrap Up
Comic-Con 2026 was packed with huge reveals! We break down every major panel, trailer, and announcement, including Spaceballs, Clayface, Lanterns, Avengers: Doomsday, Queen of the Damned, Reacher, Carrie, Neuromancer, Avatar: Seven Havens, and The Rings of Power Season 3.
R&R 163: Dragons, Legends & Last Daughters
Fantasy takes center stage in Episode 163 as the Rum & Regret crew reviews The Legend of Vox Machina and House of the Dragon, with quick thoughts on The Vampire Lestat and Supergirl. Grab a drink and join the conversation!
R&R 162: Spiders, Small Towns & Satan’s Night Out
Spider-Noir, supernatural mysteries, and vampires, oh my! The Rum & Regret crew discusses Spider-Noir, Widow’s Bay, and The Vampire Lestat in Episode 162. Grab a drink and join the conversation.











